The Controversies Surrounding Canonization


Affiliate Disclaimer

As an affiliate, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases. We get commissions for purchases made through links on this website from Amazon and other third parties.

Do you ever wonder how the Catholic Church decides who is worthy of being called a saint? The process of canonization, or declaring someone a saint, has been around for centuries and has been shrouded in controversy since its inception. From political motivations to controversial individuals, the canonization process has caused many debates and conflicts throughout history.

Despite the controversies surrounding it, however, the process of canonization holds immense importance for Catholics worldwide. Saints are considered role models and intercessors between God and humanity, making their lives and stories an integral part of Catholic tradition.

In this article, we will delve into the controversies surrounding canonization, exploring topics such as political influence in the decision-making process, criteria for sainthood, interpretation and verification of miracles attributed to saints, controversial figures throughout history who have been declared saints, and what the future may hold for this age-old practice in Catholicism.

The Role of Politics in Canonization

Politics plays a significant role in determining who is deemed worthy of being recognized as a saint. In the past, political pressure has been known to sway the decision-making process in canonization.

This can be seen in the case of Pope Pius XII, who was accused of staying silent during the Holocaust. Despite this controversy, he was still canonized as a saint due to the influence and lobbying efforts of individuals and groups with political ties.

Corruption in canonization is another issue that stems from politics. The desire for power and influence can lead to individuals using their connections to push through candidates for sainthood who may not be deserving or have questionable backgrounds.

This highlights the need for transparency and fairness in the process of canonization, so that it truly reflects the values and teachings of the Catholic Church rather than political agendas.

The Criteria for Sainthood

To become a saint, certain criteria must be met. The Catholic Church has specific guidelines for canonization, which include the candidate having lived a life of heroic virtue and having performed at least two miracles posthumously. However, these guidelines have evolved over time and there have been historical examples where individuals were recognized as saints without meeting all of the current criteria.

In modern times, changes have been made to the canonization process. Pope Francis streamlined the process in 2017 by eliminating one of the required miracles for candidates who died after 1950 and allowing for beatifications to take place in the candidate’s home country rather than Rome. These changes aim to make the process more accessible and efficient while maintaining its integrity.

Nonetheless, debates still arise regarding whether or not certain individuals meet the qualifications for sainthood and if politics or personal biases play a role in their recognition.

Interpretation and Verification of Miracles

Discovering and verifying miracles is an essential part of the process for becoming a saint, and the Catholic Church takes great care to ensure that each miracle is authentic. The verification process involves rigorous investigation by medical professionals, theologians, and other experts to determine whether the event was indeed miraculous. This process can take years or even decades, as the Church seeks to eliminate any doubt or religious skepticism surrounding the event.

The Church’s rigorous approach to verifying miracles reflects its commitment to maintaining its reputation for spiritual guidance and authority. The Church understands that many people look up to it for guidance and reassurance in their faith journey, which is why it strives to ensure that every miracle attributed to a potential saint passes through a strict validation process. This helps prevent any false claims from being made about supernatural occurrences while also ensuring that those who are canonized are truly deserving of their sainthood status.

Controversial Saints throughout History

You’ll learn about some saints throughout history that have caused controversy and may make you question the Church’s decision to recognize them as holy figures.

These saints are known for their saintly scandals and disputed miracles, which have left many people questioning their true intentions and motivations.

Take Saint Joan of Arc for example. While she’s now recognized as a martyr and canonized saint, during her lifetime she was accused of heresy by the Church and burned at the stake.

It wasn’t until centuries later that the Church acknowledged its mistake and declared her a saint. Similarly, Saint Christopher, who was once one of the most popular saints in Christianity, had his sainthood removed from the official calendar due to doubts surrounding his existence.

These controversies serve as a reminder that even those deemed ‘holy’ by the Church aren’t immune to scrutiny and doubt.

The Future of Canonization in the Catholic Church

If you’re curious about what’s next for the Catholic Church and its process of recognizing saints, there are some interesting developments to keep an eye on.

The modern challenges facing the church have prompted a reevaluation of the canonization process. With more scrutiny being placed on the lives of potential saints, it has become increasingly difficult to find individuals who meet all the criteria for sainthood without controversy or criticism.

In addition to modern challenges, changing traditions within the church are also pushing for a new approach to canonization. Some advocates argue that traditional methods, such as miracle-based evidence and papal approval, should be reconsidered in favor of a more communal approach where local communities can recognize their own saints.

This would allow for a broader definition of sainthood that includes individuals who may not have received recognition in past centuries due to societal biases and power dynamics within the church hierarchy.

Overall, it’ll be interesting to see how these conversations shape the future of canonization in the Catholic Church.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long does the canonization process usually take?

Have you ever wondered how long it takes for someone to be officially recognized as a saint by the Catholic Church? Well, the answer isn’t so straightforward.

The canonization process can take years, even decades, and involves several factors that can affect its duration. Controversies over canonization criteria have also arisen in recent years, with some questioning whether certain individuals truly meet the requirements for sainthood.

However, despite these debates and challenges, the Church remains committed to ensuring that those who are canonized are truly deserving of such recognition. So while it may take time and effort to go through the process, ultimately it is a way to honor those who have lived lives of exceptional holiness and inspire others to do the same.

Are there any non-Catholic saints recognized by the Catholic Church?

Did you know that the Catholic Church recognizes some non-Christian saints?

While most of the saints recognized by the church are Catholics, there are a few exceptions.

For instance, St. Moses the Ethiopian is recognized as a saint even though he was not a Christian during his lifetime. Similarly, St. George and St. Christopher are revered as saints despite being non-Christian figures from popular culture and folklore.

However, this raises questions about cultural appropriation of saintly figures and whether or not it’s appropriate to recognize non-Christian individuals as saints in the Catholic Church.

Despite these controversies, the recognition of non-Christian saints highlights the inclusivity and diversity of the Catholic faith and shows that anyone can be considered for sainthood regardless of their background or beliefs.

What is the process for removing someone from the list of saints?

Have you ever wondered if it’s possible for someone to be removed from the list of saints? Surprisingly, yes.

While rare, there have been historical removals of individuals from the list due to controversial cases.

The process for removing someone from the list is complex and involves thorough investigation by a committee of experts who examine the individual’s life, actions, and potential miracles attributed to them.

Despite this process, controversies surrounding canonization still arise as some argue that certain individuals should never have been canonized in the first place or should be removed due to new information about their lives.

Ultimately, it is up to the Church authorities to make these decisions and they are not taken lightly.

Has the canonization process ever been influenced by financial interests?

You might be surprised to learn that financial corruption and political pressure have been known to influence the canonization process.

In some cases, wealthy individuals or groups have donated large sums of money to the Vatican in exchange for a saintly title for their chosen candidate.

Additionally, there have been instances where politicians or other influential figures have lobbied for the canonization of someone they deem worthy, even if their qualifications may not truly meet the rigorous standards set forth by the Catholic Church.

It’s important to recognize that while these incidents are rare, they do occur – underscoring the need for transparency and accountability in this holy process.

How much does it cost to become a saint?

You may be surprised to learn that becoming a saint can come with a hefty price tag. The financial implications of sainthood are significant, with the cost of investigating and promoting a candidate for canonization reaching into the millions.

However, the impact on religious tourism can also bring in significant revenue for churches and local economies. Many pilgrims travel to visit shrines and relics associated with saints, bringing in money through donations, souvenirs, and hospitality services.

While some may question the commercialization of spirituality, there’s no denying that sainthood has become not only a spiritual pursuit but also a lucrative industry.


So, now you know all about the controversies surrounding canonization. Despite the Catholic Church’s best efforts to remain impartial and objective in their selection of saints, politics and personal biases can often come into play.

The criteria for sainthood are strict but subjective, and interpreting and verifying miracles is a complicated process that can also be influenced by personal beliefs.

Throughout history, there have been controversial saints who have caused division among Catholics. From Joan of Arc to Pope Pius IX, these figures have sparked debate over their worthiness for canonization.

As the Catholic Church moves forward, it’ll continue to face challenges in its selection of saints. However, by remaining transparent and accountable in its processes, it can ensure that only those truly deserving of sainthood are recognized as such.

Pedro is an active member of his local Military Community Parish. When not worshipping God and spreading his good word, you can find him spending quality time with his family.

Latest posts

  • The Role of the Holy Spirit in the Trinity

    The Role of the Holy Spirit in the Trinity

    Have you ever wondered about the Holy Spirit’s role in the Trinity? As a believer, you understand that God is one, yet exists as three persons: Father, Son, and Holy Spirit. But what exactly does the Holy Spirit do? How does He interact with humanity and empower believers like you? In this article, we will…

    Read more

  • How the Trinity is Revealed in the Bible

    How the Trinity is Revealed in the Bible

    You may have heard of the Trinity before, but what exactly does it mean? The concept of the Trinity is central to Christianity and refers to the belief that God is three persons in one: the Father, Son (Jesus Christ), and Holy Spirit. While this idea can be difficult to understand, it is revealed throughout…

    Read more

  • The Sacrament of Baptism: A New Birth

    The Sacrament of Baptism: A New Birth

    Have you ever felt like you needed a fresh start? Like your past mistakes and sins were weighing you down, preventing you from truly living in the present? If so, then the sacrament of baptism may be just what you need. Baptism is more than just a symbolic act; it is a new birth, a…

    Read more